Appeals Court Grants Man Convicted of 1995 Murders a Chance to Challenge Death Penalty
In a significant development, a man convicted of a double homicide at Ashurst Lake Campground in 1995 has been granted an opportunity to contest his death sentence. The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals recently ruled that Todd Lee Smith can present claims of inadequate legal representation to a state judge.
While the ruling does not overturn Smith’s conviction or guarantee removal from death row, it allows him to argue for a different sentence. Smith, who is 77 years old, was convicted for the brutal murders of Clarence and Elaine Tannehill, who were found dead in their travel trailer near Flagstaff. The couple had been beaten and their throats slit.
Smith was apprehended in Phoenix shortly after the murders, with evidence reportedly linking him to the crime. Witnesses had seen him camping near the victims’ site, according to the Arizona Daily Sun.
During his sentencing, Smith apologized to the victims’ family, and his defense argued that he suffered from a personality disorder, believing the victims posed a threat to him. Despite acknowledging Smith’s disorder, Coconino County Superior Court Judge Jeffrey Coker concluded that Smith could control his behavior and sentenced him to death.
A federal judge initially denied Smith’s request to present new evidence concerning his sentencing, but the appeals court disagreed. Their decision highlighted shortcomings in the legal representation Smith received post-conviction. The appellate judges noted, “(She) admits she never interviewed Smith, failed to investigate Smith’s case beyond the existing trial record, and did not conduct an independent investigation into a mitigation case for Smith.”
Mitigating circumstances, such as mental illness or intellectual disability, play a crucial role in death penalty cases. Smith’s current claim asserts that his post-conviction attorney did not investigate possible mitigating evidence, including his fetal alcohol syndrome and brain damage.
The appeals court also acknowledged that Smith had not intentionally delayed proceedings and referenced a 2022 U.S. Supreme Court ruling that changes the criteria for seeking a federal court stay while presenting claims of ineffective counsel to a state judge.
Meanwhile, in an unrelated incident, Grand Canyon National Park officials reported the discovery of a Comanche aircraft and debris field in the Basin area, highlighting the varied challenges faced by authorities in the region.
—
Read More Arizona News








