Michigan Court Upholds Ban on State-Funded Abortions for Low-Income Residents
In a pivotal decision impacting low-income women in Michigan, a judge has dismissed a legal challenge against the state’s prohibition on taxpayer-funded abortions. This ruling comes amid a landscape where the right to abortion is constitutionally recognized, yet financial support for the procedure remains restricted by longstanding policies.
Despite Michigan voters approving a constitutional amendment in 2022 affirming abortion rights, the ban on most state-funded abortions has persisted, unaffected by shifts in political control.
The lawsuit, initiated by YWCA Kalamazoo, argued that the organization’s funding of abortions for over 75% of women in southwestern Michigan should be recognized. Many of these women would qualify for state assistance if Medicaid covered abortion costs.
Judge Brock Swartzle of the Michigan Court of Claims ruled on July 3 that YWCA Kalamazoo lacked the standing to sue. According to the judge’s 18-page opinion, “The YWCA is not an individual and it, as a nonprofit organization, does not have reproductive freedom. Further, the YWCA does not provide abortion care and is not directly affected by a law that denies funding for abortions.”
Currently, Michigan’s Medicaid policies allow funding for abortions only under circumstances where the woman’s life is at risk or in cases of rape or incest. This stands in contrast to 17 other states where Medicaid encompasses abortion services, as noted by the American Civil Liberties Union and the law firm Goodwin Procter, who represent YWCA Kalamazoo.
Ann Mullen, spokesperson for the ACLU, commented that the ban “can delay, and even prevent, access to vital health care. We and our clients are evaluating possible next steps.”
Meanwhile, Right to Life of Michigan, a group that consistently supports the Medicaid funding restrictions, welcomed the court’s decision. President Amber Roseboom stated, “Proposal 3 guarantees access to abortion, not carte blanche funding of elective abortions at the expense of every Michigan taxpayer.”
—
Read More Michigan News
