Michigan Supreme Court Delivers Mixed Ruling on Renewable Energy Law

Michigan's renewable energy law allows state to override strict local zoning rules, sparking mixed reactions in court.
Michigan Supreme Court Delivers Mixed Ruling on Renewable Energy Law

Michigan Supreme Court’s Decision Sparks Diverse Reactions in Renewable Energy Zoning Debate

A recent ruling by the Michigan Supreme Court on the state’s renewable energy zoning law has led to mixed reactions from both supporters and opponents. The 2023 law, known as P.A. 233, allows the Michigan Public Service Commission (MPSC) to override local zoning ordinances for renewable energy projects if these are deemed excessively restrictive. This law specifies criteria for ordinances, covering aspects such as fencing, height, and noise regulations.

Local governments across Michigan opposed this interpretation, arguing for their autonomy, but faced a setback when the Court of Appeals sided with the MPSC. The Supreme Court’s recent order largely upheld the law, a decision celebrated by environmental advocates, including the Michigan Energy Innovation Business Council.

Laura Sherman, President of the Michigan Energy Innovation Business Council, emphasized the importance of collaboration between renewable energy developers and local authorities. She stated, “If you want to be assured that a project cannot go to the state, then you set up a local ordinance that has these very clear requirements. Today, [it] has been affirmed by the Supreme Court that those are the simple requirements.”

Despite the ruling, township lawyers found some solace in parts of the decision. Originally, the MPSC had limited the definition of “affected local unit” to governments with direct zoning authority over a project site. However, the Supreme Court broadened this definition to include any local government impacted by a project.

According to Michael D. Homier, the lead attorney for the townships, this was a significant win for municipalities without zoning power but still affected by renewable projects. He noted, “The decision confirms that those communities cannot be excluded from the rights and protections the Legislature provided under PA 233 simply because another local government exercises zoning jurisdiction.”

As the legal proceedings progress, the Michigan Supreme Court is set to address the timeline for local governments’ responses to developers. Sherman pointed out that although the law allows local regulation, indefinite delays are not permissible, aligning with the Legislature’s intent for timely decisions.

For detailed insights, refer to the official documents: the state law, the Court of Appeals decision, and the Supreme Court order.

—
Read More Michigan News

Share the Post:

Subscribe

Related Posts