A debate over earmarks in Michigan’s budget process has taken the spotlight, as State Rep. Jim DeSana, who has typically criticized such spending, seeks $1.75 million for a stadium renovation in his district. The proposed grant would enhance the baseball venue in Taylor’s Heritage Park, which annually hosts the Junior League World Series.
DeSana, a Carleton Republican, pointed to new transparency measures in the House budget process, which included extensive public hearings. “I think that an earmark that benefits a private individual or a private company is especially egregious, but this earmark just benefits the downriver communities, especially Taylor,” he remarked to Bridge Michigan.
With a passion for baseball, DeSana contributes to the Michigan Monarchs collegiate summer team and offers pitching and batting lessons from his Carleton home. The requested funds, together with contributions from Taylor city and private donors, aim to provide new facilities, seating, and lighting at the stadium.
This funding request marks a first for DeSana, who has been a vocal critic of earmarks, labeling them as a “quid pro quo.” However, he argues that this case is distinct, as it involves a public park and boosts local economic activity. “I think that legitimately, this falls under that whole broad category of how to improve your community parks and recreation,” he added.
Controversy and Reforms
Michigan’s history with earmarks is fraught with controversy, often due to projects being slipped into legislation at odd hours. Instances have included funds directed towards private enterprises and politically connected individuals, sometimes leading to criminal probes. For more information on past earmarks, visit Bridge Michigan.
House Republicans, led by Speaker Matt Hall, R-Richland Township, are pushing for reform. New transparency rules now demand that lawmakers submit requests by May 1, allowing for public scrutiny well before votes. In this cycle, nearly $3.4 billion was requested for 791 projects, ranging from infrastructure repairs to community services.
The House Labor and Economic Opportunity Subcommittee recently reviewed these requests, with Rep. Nancy Jenkins-Arno of Clayton noting the challenge of prioritizing state funding amidst extensive needs.
Political Dynamics
While the House adheres to its new transparent process, its compatibility with the Democratic-led Senate remains uncertain. Hall has insisted that non-compliant requests will be excluded from the budget. “I don’t care who the politician is. I don’t care what the program is. We’re not making an exception,” Hall stated emphatically.
Governor Gretchen Whitmer has also advocated for earmark reform, aligning with efforts for greater transparency. Yet, as negotiations continue past a missed budget deadline, the fate of earmarks in the final budget remains uncertain.
House Democrats, although part of the advance request filing, have criticized the hearings as political maneuvering. Jess Travers, a spokesperson for the Democrats, emphasized their focus on achieving a comprehensive budget that secures essential services like school lunches and Medicaid.
For the original story, visit Bridge Michigan.
—
Read More Michigan News
