Supreme Court Ruling Supports Michigan’s Counting of Late Mail-In Ballots
In a significant move, the U.S. Supreme Court has affirmed the legality of counting mail-in ballots that reach clerks’ offices after Election Day, a decision that directly impacts Michigan’s electoral processes. This decision, originating from a Mississippi case, ensures that military and overseas ballots postmarked by Election Day can be counted even if they arrive later.
Michigan is among approximately 30 states that provide a grace period for late-arriving mail-in ballots. According to Michigan’s regulations, overseas ballots are accepted if they arrive within six days post-election, as long as they are postmarked by Election Day.
Christopher Thomas, a former Michigan elections director, noted the challenges faced by U.S. citizens in the military and those residing overseas. “You may be dealing with other countries’ postal services as part of the return process. It’s all basically disadvantageous to them,” he explained.
The decision was welcomed by Democratic Secretary of State Jocelyn Benson, who saw it as a triumph for voting rights and state autonomy in managing election procedures. “It’s a win for military servicemembers and citizens living overseas who can cast their ballot with confidence, knowing that their voice will be heard,” she stated.
She further emphasized, “Every Michigan voter has the right to vote by mail, and every state has the constitutional authority to run our own elections. We will continue to follow the law and fight to ensure every eligible citizen can vote in every election.”
This ruling aligns with reforms from a 2022 voting rights amendment, which was supported by 60% of Michigan voters, ensuring that ballots postmarked by Election Day are counted even if they arrive late. Christy McGillivray of Voters Not Politicians highlighted that the decision affirms the state’s control over election methods and maintains the integrity of the amendment endorsed by Michigan voters.
However, the ruling was met with criticism from the state Republican Party. Chair Jim Runestad expressed concerns, stating, “Let’s have an Election Day, not election week, not election month, because mischief can occur. Anyone who knows there’s an election coming up should be mailing their ballot in or bringing their ballot or voting on Election Day without this open door to potential fraud.”
The Supreme Court majority clarified that concerns about election security should be tackled by legislative bodies rather than the courts.
In a related development, the U.S. Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals recently ruled that the federal government could not compel Michigan to release confidential voter roll data. This decision is expected to be appealed by the Trump administration to the Supreme Court.
—
Read More Michigan News
