A pivotal legal decision has emerged in the ongoing battle over access to voter data. A federal judge has dismissed a lawsuit by the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) aimed at compelling Arizona to release detailed voter records. This ruling marks a significant setback for the DOJ’s broader initiative to obtain voter information across various states.
U.S. District Judge Susan Brnovich, appointed by former President Trump, ruled against the DOJ’s efforts, stating that Arizona’s voter registration list does not fall under documents accessible by the Attorney General under current federal law. She further emphasized that any amendment to the lawsuit would be “legally futile,” leading to the case’s dismissal with prejudice.
This decision is part of a broader trend, as similar DOJ lawsuits have been dismissed in multiple states, including Rhode Island, California, Massachusetts, Michigan, and Oregon. In another instance, a lawsuit in Georgia was dismissed due to being filed in the incorrect jurisdiction, necessitating the DOJ to refile it elsewhere.
The Arizona lawsuit originally targeted Secretary of State Adrian Fontes for non-compliance with the DOJ’s request. Fontes expressed satisfaction with the ruling, stating, “This moment is a win for voter privacy. I will never comply with illegal requests that put Arizona voters in harm’s way.”
The DOJ has not provided an immediate comment following the decision. Meanwhile, at least 13 states have agreed or are in the process of agreeing to furnish their voter registration lists to the DOJ. These states include Alaska, Arkansas, Indiana, Louisiana, Mississippi, Nebraska, Ohio, Oklahoma, South Carolina, South Dakota, Tennessee, Texas, and Wyoming, as per data from the Brennan Center and Associated Press.
Federal officials argue that access to voter data is critical for ensuring adherence to federal election laws governing voter registration list maintenance. Notably, in the Rhode Island case, a DOJ lawyer admitted the intent to share unredacted voter information with the Department of Homeland Security for citizenship verification purposes.
Despite these assertions, there is bipartisan resistance at the state level, with both Democratic and some Republican leaders opposing the DOJ’s demands, citing potential breaches of state and federal privacy laws.
A new Arizona law expands death benefits for first responders. It’s partly inspired by the death of DPS pilot Robert Skankey, who died in a helicopter crash while responding to a Flagstaff shooting.
—
Read More Arizona News
