Older Americans Face Renewed Student Loan Collections as Debt Crisis Deepens
The resumption of student loan collections by the Trump administration has unexpectedly brought financial distress to a surprising demographic: older Americans. With their decades-old debts, many seniors now face the risk of having their Social Security checks garnished, a development that threatens their already precarious financial stability.
Linda Hilton, a 76-year-old retiree from Apache Junction, knows the struggle too well, having faced garnishment before the COVID-19 pandemic. She now braces for a future with fewer luxuries, possibly foregoing travel and dining out.
Christine Farro, aged 73, has spent years cutting costs to manage her tight budget. With her student loan payments paused during the pandemic, she now expects her Social Security to be garnished once more, further straining her finances.
“I worked ridiculous hours. I worked weekends and nights. But I could never pay it off,” Farro, a retired child welfare worker from Santa Ynez, California, explains of her decades-long struggle with student loan debt.
The pause on federal student loan payments and interest, initiated five years ago to ease pandemic-induced economic hardship, ended in 2023. Now, the Department of Education has restarted “involuntary collections” on defaulted loans, including garnishing Social Security benefits.
Farro’s loans, originating over 40 years ago, have ballooned to $250,000 due to compound interest and missed payments. Despite consolidating her loans and paying $1,000 monthly, her debt remains insurmountable.
The student loan burden among older Americans has soared, partly due to rising tuition costs. The National Consumer Law Center reports that individuals aged 60 and older hold approximately $125 billion in student loans, a six-fold increase over the past two decades.
Statistics from the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau reveal a dramatic 3,000% increase in Social Security beneficiaries experiencing garnishment, rising from about 6,200 in 2001 to 192,300 in 2019.
Debbie McIntyre, a 62-year-old educator in Kentucky, dreams of retiring but is trapped by her husband’s disability and looming garnishment threats. The couple relies on credit to supplement their income, and McIntyre fears the impact of garnished wages on their financial future.
The situation for many seniors is dire, with some considering bankruptcy, though student loans are not easily discharged. Others, like McIntyre, are resorting to side jobs to chip away at their debts.
Debt Collective’s Braxton Brewington highlights the severe consequences faced by those subjected to garnishment, noting that many older debtors have repaid their principal several times over, yet remain in debt due to interest and fees.
“We hear from people who skip meals. We know people who dilute their medication or cut their pills in half,” Brewington reports, illustrating the extreme measures some take to cope.
The Biden administration has attempted to limit income garnishment, but federal law only protects $750 of Social Security benefits from being seized, leaving many below the poverty line. Sarah Sattelmeyer of New America criticizes the situation, saying, “We’re basically providing people with federal benefits with one hand and taking them away with another.”
Amid these challenges, some debtors have received collection notices, while others live in fear of what’s to come. President Trump’s executive order to dismantle the Department of Education has further complicated the issue by leading to mass layoffs, making it difficult for borrowers to get answers.
Education Secretary Linda McMahon argues that resuming collections is crucial for both debtors’ financial health and the nation’s economy. Nonetheless, even some of Trump’s supporters question the hardships these policies impose.
Randall Countryman, 55, who once supported Trump, now wishes for more nuanced decisions regarding debtors, emphasizing that the student loan crisis is not just a young person’s issue. “What’s a young person’s problem today,” he notes, “is an old person’s problem tomorrow.”
Countryman’s own experience with student loans reflects these challenges. Despite not completing his degree, he accrued significant debt and now relies on his wife’s Social Security and his mother-in-law’s support, uncertain of how they would cope if forced to repay.
He reflects, “I kind of wish I never went to school in the first place.”
—
Read More Arizona News
