Michigan Secretary of State Challenges Legislative Subpoena in Court
A legal battle is unfolding in Michigan as Secretary of State Jocelyn Benson challenges a subpoena issued by a Republican-led legislative committee. Benson, a Democrat and gubernatorial candidate, contends that the committee’s actions exceed its authority and has sought judicial intervention to block the enforcement of the subpoena.
The conflict centers around election-related materials, with the House Oversight Committee, led by Republicans, seeking detailed information on election training and management. Although Benson’s office has partially complied, further disclosure has been withheld pending review and redaction of sensitive information that could compromise election security or endanger election workers.
Benson’s recent court filing emphasizes the constitutional limitations on legislative oversight, arguing that the committee is using its subpoena power as a political tool rather than for legitimate legislative purposes. The filing asserts, “A committee cannot exercise its subpoena power in a subverted effort to try an officer for suspected violation of the law, and its investigative power cannot be wielded under the guise of punishing those investigated.”
House Oversight Committee Chair Jay DeBoyer, a Republican from Clay, insists that the Legislature’s authority in this matter is clear and non-negotiable. Speaking to Michigan Public Radio, DeBoyer remarked, “We make that determination. This isn’t a partnership. This is the Legislature trying to make decisions in the best interests of the people of the State of Michigan.”
The Michigan Court of Claims will soon weigh in on the issue, with a deadline set for July 3 for the House to present its counterarguments. Judge Sima Patel’s decision is anticipated to be closely watched, as an appeal is expected regardless of the outcome.
—
Read More Michigan News
