Impairment Looms for Big Hole River Amid Algal Growth Concerns

The Big Hole River faces a eutrophication impairment. This designation aims to address algae growth caused by excess nutrients.
Big Hole River to serve as testing ground for new water-quality regulations

An algae bloom photographed on the Lower Big Hole River near Wisdom on July 14, 2025. Low streamflows can contribute to algal blooms, which deplete rivers of the oxygen cold-water fish need to thrive. Credit: Dan Armstrong

DIVIDE — The renowned Big Hole River, known for its blue-ribbon fishery status, faces potential impairment designation due to persistent nuisance algae issues.

At a recent meeting in Divide, Montana, the Department of Environmental Quality (DEQ) revealed that nutrient pollution is severely impacting the river’s ecosystem. The term “eutrophication” highlights the overgrowth of algae linked to high levels of nutrients like nitrogen and phosphorus, which lower dissolved oxygen, threatening fish and aquatic life.

Recreation users find algal growth problematic, making wade-fishing hazardous and reducing macroinvertebrate biodiversity, crucial for aquatic ecosystems. Andy Ulven from DEQ stated the eutrophication listing would confirm ongoing issues with nutrient levels in the Big Hole, but a final decision isn’t expected until 2027.

The impairment designation could serve as a framework for other rivers affected by eutrophication. DEQ’s Darrin Kron noted that such a designation would lead to regulations reducing pollutants through Total Maximum Daily Loads (TMDLs), akin to a “pollution diet” for the river. Standards for nitrogen, phosphorus, and temperature may be established to combat low oxygen levels.

Increased public funding is anticipated for conservation efforts by groups like the Big Hole Watershed Committee and Trout Unlimited, focusing on river-restoration projects. Common nutrient pollution sources include agricultural runoff and livestock waste.

Scottsdale district to close 2 schools. Community members call decision-making process flawed
Anglers make their way down the Big Hole on Sept. 27, 2025. In late August, the Big Hole dropped so low that Montana Fish, Wildlife and Parks closed the entire river to fishing. Credit: Chris Boyer/Lighthawk.org

Efforts by groups like Upper Missouri Waterkeeper and Save Wild Trout to reduce nutrient pollution have been ongoing, with accusations of political avoidance from Guy Alsentzer of Waterkeeper. The controversy revolves around numeric vs. narrative standards for controlling nutrient levels, with recent legislation prohibiting numeric standards.

House Bill 664, backing narrative standards, faces a lawsuit for allegedly violating the Clean Water Act. Judge Brian Morris’ ruling could impact DEQ’s approach to nutrient standards.

Ongoing drought and low water levels in the Big Hole Basin intensify water quality worries. Erik Kalsta, a local rancher, is concerned about the implications during drought conditions, noting substantially reduced irrigation capacity.

Brian Wheeler of Save Wild Trout emphasizes the importance of maintaining clean water under limited supply, noting the river’s unusually low water levels.

LATEST STORIES


Read More Montana News

Share the Post:

Subscribe

Related Posts