Bresnahan Denies Supporting Vouchers Despite Funding Private Schools

Article Summary –

Essential Facts and Data

Rob Bresnahan, the Republican nominee for Pennsylvania’s 8th Congressional District, denied supporting the use of public education funds for private and religious schools during a debate, despite prior statements endorsing school choice and voucher systems. In contrast, Democratic incumbent Rep. Matt Cartwright criticized voucher programs for diverting funds from public schools and has been endorsed by major teachers’ unions. Experts argue that school vouchers harm public education and have not improved student achievement, with research indicating negative outcomes in states implementing such programs.

Rob Bresnahan, Republican nominee for Pennsylvania’s 8th Congressional District, stated in an Oct. 22 debate with Democratic Rep. Matt Cartwright that he opposes using public education funds for private and religious schools. This contradicts earlier comments Bresnahan made on the topic.

The Cook Political Report considers the race between Cartwright and Bresnahan a toss-up. Cartwright emphasized his support for public education, contrasting it with Bresnahan’s alleged backing of a voucher system that diverts public funds to private schooling, benefiting those already attending private schools. Bresnahan retorted, “I don’t even know what school voucher program you’re referencing.”

Cartwright explained school vouchers as diverting funds from public schools, but Bresnahan interrupted, denying support for such programs. However, just days before, he expressed support for expanding school choice, advocating for educational options like vocational training and homeschooling, suggesting federal incentives for states to offer more choices.

In a July 30 interview with Hugh Hewitt, Bresnahan reaffirmed his support for school choice, stating, “The dollar should follow the child.” A request for comment from Bresnahan’s campaign went unanswered.

Experts argue that school voucher programs using taxpayer funds for private tuition harm public schools, hurt low-income students, and fail to improve student outcomes. States with vouchers report worsened education outcomes.

Cartwright, endorsed by the National Education Association and the American Federation of Teachers, Pennsylvania, stated post-debate that diverting funds from public to private education is “reckless,” emphasizing his commitment to public education.