Efforts to reduce egg prices in Arizona have taken a new turn as Gov. Katie Hobbs seeks to delay cage-free egg regulations. However, the anticipated savings for consumers may be minimal.
Gov. Hobbs has directed the state Department of Agriculture to postpone the implementation of cage-free egg requirements until 2034. This decision aims to alleviate financial pressures on producers and retailers, ultimately benefiting consumers.
Despite these intentions, the expected reduction in egg prices might not significantly impact Arizona residents’ grocery bills. Initial estimates by the agency suggested that transitioning from 67-square-inch enclosures to open-barn systems would save consumers between 12 to 39 cents per dozen eggs, with current prices hovering close to $6.
With an average annual consumption of over 270 eggs per person, this translates to potential savings of $2.71 to $8.79 per individual.
Christian Slater, the governor’s press aide, acknowledged the limited relief this measure provides, emphasizing that egg prices have surged due to the avian influenza outbreak. He maintained that it’s crucial for elected officials to take action on everyday issues affecting citizens.
According to the U.S. Department of Agriculture, egg prices could increase by another 20% this year, further complicating the situation.
This decision coincides with a proposal by Sen. Shawnna Bolick to eliminate the Department of Agriculture’s authority to regulate cage sizes. Bolick’s bill, SB 1721, aims to provide grocery bill relief and has already passed the Senate along party lines.
While Slater insisted that the timing of Hobbs’ announcement was unrelated to the upcoming legislative hearing, the decision to delay the regulation until 2034 may offer political leverage if the governor decides to veto Bolick’s legislation.
The initial push for cage-free regulations stemmed from the Humane Society of the United States, which threatened to pursue a voter initiative banning caged hen egg sales. In response, the egg industry sought legislative intervention to create a more favorable timeline and avoid criminal penalties.
Although the Department of Agriculture initially scheduled the cage-free requirement for 2027, the agency has agreed to postponements, with Hobbs now proposing an additional seven-year delay.
The debate over hen housing regulations may become irrelevant due to a lawsuit filed by the Goldwater Institute on behalf of Tucson restaurant owner Grant Krueger. Krueger argues that the Department of Agriculture lacks the authority to establish such rules, a power he contends resides solely with the Legislature.
Krueger’s lawsuit survived an initial legal challenge when Maricopa County Superior Court Judge Scott Blaney ruled that Krueger had standing to sue. Krueger claims his restaurants could face quantifiable economic harm, having purchased over 104,000 eggs in a year, equating to $3,380 annually based on the agency’s cost estimates.
The case awaits trial, with no date currently set.
—
Read More Arizona News
